Searching for a light to dispel the darkness

Maryclaire Andrews describes herself as ''by nature a cynical person … if something sounds too good to be true, it certainly is.'' But the Perth woman's reflexive scepticism has met a big challenge this year.
Nanjing Night Net

On February 28 she flew to Boca Raton, Florida, with her long-time partner, Basil Renolds. The following day Renolds, diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease three years ago, had the first of eight treatments he would receive over two months at the Institute of Neurological Recovery.

As he was tilted backwards at a 45 degree angle, an immune system drug called etanercept was injected between the bones at the top of his spine. The rationale is that a combination of gravity and the rich blood vessel supply in the area known as Batson's plexus will carry a concentrated hit of the medicine right into the brain, evading the filters that prevent such large molecules entering brain tissue when drugs are delivered by mouth or intravenously.

''He became less anxious, more sure, able to sign his name the way he used to,'' Andrews says. The benefits persisted and on his return to Australia, Andrews says, Renolds's score on the mini mental state examination - a test used to benchmark the condition of dementia patients - had improved.

He now flies monthly to Queensland to receive top-up doses of the drug, sold under the brand name Enbrel, from a doctor understood to be the only one in Australia trained to administer the therapy by its originator, Dr Ed Tobinick. The Queensland doctor would not allow the Herald to know his identity.

But despite Renolds's experience and that of hundreds of others in his situation, the combination of drug and delivery technique, over which Tobinick holds dozens of well-guarded patents, has never been scientifically proven through the established protocols of clinical trials in which the drug and a placebo are compared in carefully selected patients.

Tobinick's work is not without a scientific track record, but he is the author of most papers about it. His most recent publication, in the journal Current Alzheimer Research, seeks to explain the central puzzle: how the technique can achieve such dramatic results so quickly.

The drug - which targets tumour necrosis factor (TNF), a cause of inflammation - diffused into the cerebro-spinal fluid if the two were maintained in proximity by the effect of gravity, according to the paper.

This fluid, Tobinick wrote, was in direct contact with some brain cells, and it appeared these could respond to the drug without it having to pass through the blood vessels of the brain - in opposition to medical dogma.

His paper cited other scientists' findings that TNF levels were abnormally high in the spinal fluid of Alzheimer's patients, but not in their blood, arguing that the drug's direct administration into the affected region was the most likely explanation for the sudden recovery.

Ian Clark, from the Research School of Biology at the Australian National University, where he studies the inflammation factors targeted by etanercept, said Dr Tobinick was ''doing exactly the right thing. He's worked out a way to get [the drug] in that's novel and perfectly legitimate … it's not remotely a crackpot thing to do.'' Why, then, would the companies that market etanercept not want to test it extensively in their own clinical trials - the usual way new treatments are brought into the mainstream?

Enbrel, created by the US biotechnology company Amgen and marketed internationally by Pfizer for conditions including rheumatoid arthritis and psoriasis, already earns the companies $3 billion a year. An extension into Alzheimer's before an anticipated tsunami of new cases as the population ages could be a much bigger bonanza.

In Australia alone, the number of people suffering the currently irreversible disease is expected to double to more than half a million by 2030, according to projections by Deloitte Access Economics.

Tobinick told the Herald he believed the pharmaceutical industry was wary of the unusual and invasive route of administration that his technique entails.

''It's much easier to [deliver drugs] intravenously, subcutaneously or orally,'' he says.

''Even epidural is a more standard method of delivery. But none of those have the same effect.''

Pfizer's only investigation of Enbrel in Alzheimer's is a study through the University of Southampton in Britain, in which the drug is injected under the skin. Tobinick said it was doomed to fail.

''Only about half of 1 per cent of these large molecules will penetrate'' into the brain if the drug is administered that way, he says.

As well, Tobinick says, companies were heavily committed to a different therapeutic approach - developing medicines to remove the sticky plaques of the protein beta-amyloid that clog the brains of people with Alzheimer's - to divert to an older drug with less future patent protection that might nullify their investment.

Tobinick says he would welcome an industry-sponsored investigation of his techniques, and in the meantime hoped to conduct a study in primates to demonstrate whether and how Enbrel infiltrated the brain. He has already conducted a similar experiment in rats, radio-labelling the drug so it shows up using positron electron tomography scans.

However, Henry Brodaty rejects Tobinick's assessment of the lack of formal research, calling it a ''conspiracy theory''.

The Scientia Professor of Ageing and Mental Health at the Dementia Collaborative Research Centre, based at the University of NSW, says the industry has been open to trying new ways of giving Alzheimer's drugs - as witnessed by a successful small scale trial announced last week of Gammagard, derived from human blood by the US company Baxter International, which appeared to halt progression of the disease. Gammagard must be infused intravenously.

''I think drug companies are into making money,'' Brodaty says. ''If they thought [perispinal Enbrel] was a winner, they would back it.''

Just last week, Pfizer and Johnson & Johnson pulled the plug on a trial of a drug called bapineuzumab, an antibody treatment that attempted to dissolve the protein blockages in the brain.

The trial, in patients with mild to moderate forms of the disease, found no benefit to those taking the treatment compared with a placebo. It leaves only one beta-amyloid drug contender - Eli Lilly's solanezumab - in active late-stage study.

Sally Chege, a healthcare neurology analyst at the US market research firm GlobalData, said the failed bapineuzumab trial, which follows other unsuccessful beta-amyloid studies, was bad news for drug companies, which were ''redirect[ing] resources towards [cancer treatment] where endpoints are clearer and drug approval is less difficult''.

It is also, clearly, bad news for patients, who are out of options. Existing treatments Reminyl, Aricept and Ebixa improve some symptoms in a minority of patients but do not slow the underlying progression of the disease. Nothing effectively intervenes in the devastating one-way journey of Alzheimer's, which robs not only memory but ordinary daily functioning and personality, and is invariably fatal if the person does not die first from another cause.

Desperate for anything that will hold back the relentless disease even temporarily, patients clutch at straws.

An editorial last week in The New England Journal of Medicine reflected on the possible reworking of yet another old drug - the cancer treatment bexarotene - as Alzheimer's therapy. Its stunning effect in clearing beta-amyloid plaques from mice genetically engineered to develop them meant doctors would inevitably field requests from patients, wrote Justin Lowenthal from the US National Institutes of Health's Department of Bioethics.

But he concluded that even though such prescription would be legal, because of the lack of human safety and effectiveness research, ''even if patients and families are willing to take the risks for the potential benefit, the physician's answer should be no''.

Henry Brodaty fears the quest for effective Alzheimer's medications will be a much longer haul. The mice treated with bexarotene, he points out, regressed a few weeks later. Besides, mice bred to mimic a human disease may not really be a good clinical model of it. ''We've had so many promising studies in these transgenic mice but Alzheimer's is a much more complex disease than just the amyloid,'' he says.

Despite the clinical trial failures so far, beta-amyloid could still be an important drug target, says Brodaty, pointing to the discovery last month of a gene mutation that slows its production and protects against Alzheimer's - even in people otherwise at high genetic risk.

''Maybe you need multiple therapies,'' Brodaty says. ''It may be that once the iceberg has risen above the water line it is too late,'' and treatment may need to be given before any symptoms appear. But that, he says, raises its own risks, if seemingly healthy people were to undergo testing and find they were on course to develop an incurable dementia.

For Basil Renolds, it is immaterial that Tobinick's treatment - which has so far cost about $12,000 - is unproven. It does not restore all his functions, Maryclaire Andrews says, but it lets him walk the dog and confidently make a cup of tea.

''If I can keep him with no deterioration, that's a plus,'' she says. ''It's not a cure by any means but if it keeps people in a more stable state, it's got to be the way to go until something better comes along. When you look at the ballooning cost of dementia … holy smoke! Why do you just not look at this?''

This story Administrator ready to work first appeared on Nanjing Night Net.

By admin, ago

Rich fellow my country

A picture to behold ... lying under azure skies and bathed in warm 30-degree temperatures, Darwin serves an ideal antidote to the rip and rush of southern life.Even in this dry season, with its generous parks and open space browned off by months without rain, Darwin is a picture to behold. Looking out over the Arafura Sea, towards an Asia that increasingly is its natural economic fit and bathed in unfailing 30-degree temperatures and azure skies, Australia's most northern capital projects a calm nonchalance, a sort of manana without the sense of urgency, an ideal antidote to the rip and rush of southern life.
Nanjing Night Net

It's a picture that belies reality, however. The Northern Territory, and particularly its capital, is being asked to make its most dramatic shift since cyclone Tracy flattened Darwin on Christmas Eve, 1974.

The lifestyle for which so many Darwinites chose to eschew points south and to take up residence remote from family, friends and past is under challenge by resource-mania, a headlong rush to grab some of the spoils lavished for decades on the neighbours to the west and the east - Western Australia and Queensland.

A $34 billion investment is in progress to pump gas condensate 885 kilometres from the Browse Basin off the Kimberley coast to Darwin, where it can be converted to liquefied natural gas (LNG) for shipping to Japan.

The Ichthys project, by its Japanese owner Inpex, comes on top of the existing ConocoPhillips onshore processing of gas from the Timor Sea, and is the heftiest addition to a grand plan to make Darwin a rival to the North West Shelf as a gas hub.

For all of Darwin's false starts, for all the hype over three decades, that Darwin was about to score a future beyond the roles of northern administrator and defence bulwark (it's biggest employers), Darwin's time in the economic glow of what Australia does best may eventually have arrived.

Now, that's not disconcerting to most Territorians. Jobs that earn income rather than spend revenue have always been short. Individuals reckon they can prosper, although just how many of the 20,000 jobs being talked up by the government will be occupied by Territorians or by fly-in, fly-out workers is unclear.

Collectively, too, there's dignity and pride in paying your way rather than having to wear the condescension of southern paymasters who prop up the Territory with annual GST payments equivalent of $12,200 per Territorian (compared with $2200 nationally) and 25 per cent of federal specific purpose payments for education, health and so on even though the Territory has just 1 per cent of Australia's population. Sixty 60 per cent of Darwin workers are on the public payroll.

The tone of acceptance, even enthusiasm, for the new Darwin, however, is not universal. Philip Nitschke, for instance, is in a quandary over whether to stay at Humpty Doo, a settlement outside Darwin. "There's been massive change to accommodate the gas and military influx," says the medical practitioner and euthanasia advocate.

"A lot of people come here to find a place that was quiet, tropical and idyllic. That's less so every day, leaving people apprehensive because Darwin is just becoming another sprawling urban development, with infrastructure and planning never catching up. It's very much one of several capital cities now."

Nitschke, who arrived 39 years ago, is contemplating a shift to Adelaide River, 100 kilometres to Darwin's south, although he says "I don't know what I'm going to do".

Perhaps the monsoonal wet season, and its oppressive precursor - what Territorians call the Build Up - will deliver a inverted relief. "The caravan convoys (which clog Darwin camping facilities in the dry) will return south, and you'll be able to get a car park again in Cavenagh and Mitchell streets (in the city). But you can't go about your business walking around in stubbies and thongs any more."

That's the thing with the Top End: it is back to front. The rain buckets down while the rest of the country watches cricket; when the heat most calls you to the beach, the nasties keep you out of the water.

The contradictions, from a southern perspective, flow through politics, too, and will be put to the test next Saturday at the polls.

Labor's bedrock vote since self-government in 1978 has been the third of Territorians who are Aboriginal or Islander. The natural ally of business has been the Country Liberal Party, which held the reins for the first 23 years and has been out of the saddle since.

Both these assumptions have been turned on their heads. For the first time, four prominent indigenous candidates are standing for the CLP. Labor copped a thumping from indigenous voters at the 2010 federal election and is still on the nose with some who support the Howard Government's 2007 Intervention and some opponents of this firmer management of Aboriginal communities who blame the ALP for extending it. Labor paternalism has come to equate with patronisation and the encouragement of indolence and dependency.

Another sore point is the Territory government's abolition of Aboriginal community councils and their replacement by so-called super shires, which lack skills and funding and, in the eyes of angry Aborigines, deny them self-determination.

If the CLP can secure the "bush" seats contested by its new black alliance, Labor - already a minority government with 12 of the 25 assembly seats - would seem doomed. After all, the Labor contagion seems to have reached the Territory. The Chief Minister, Paul Henderson, has done as much as he can to quarantine his government, rebranding Labor as "the Henderson team" and keeping Julia Gillard out of the picture.

The problem in forecasting election results is that the Territory genuinely is quirky, Labor has established itself as a business ally - it lured Inpex and is building an impressive marine supply base in Darwin - and the bush seats aren't polled even though each of the 25 electorates has only 5000 enrolled.

Small numbers give incumbency a potent advantage. "If you're a sitting MP and don't know most of your voters, you are doing something very wrong," says former CLP leader and now a political consultant Jodeen Carney, who spent 10 years as an MP. "This is going to be a very close election, except in Alice Springs (a CLP stronghold). The question is whether the opposition is credible and whether the government has done enough."

By most accounts, the CLP leader, Terry Mills, is a good bloke but an ineffective politician. Most people know his job is in the sights of Dave Tollner, a bluster merchant who represented the Darwin-based seat of Solomon in federal Parliament but now is nipping at the heels of Mills from within.

And has the government done enough? Henderson, a onetime marine fitter, has an abrasive manner and a propensity for projecting the government as a manifestation of himself. When he proposed a public-funded music event to be called Hendo's Big Bash, Territorians thought he'd gone far enough.

Henderson dumped his predecessor Clare Martin - who delivered Labor from the wilderness with a surprise victory in 2001 - and then called a snap election at which it lost six seats. A year later, Labor lost its one-seat majority when Alison Anderson quit and joined the CLP as its first indigenous MP.

Gerry Wood, a conservative-leaning independent, was left the kingmaker. He told the Herald this week he threw Labor the lifeline because three years ago, "Inpex was on the way and sources told me the Japanese didn't like unstable government." Labor had been elected with a one-seat majority and the surest way of securing stability, Wood said, was for him to back the government on the proviso Henderson's leadership not be challenged. "This made them all pull their socks up and they have."

That, though, depends on whose opinion you seek.

Darwin incomes have a healthy premium above the national average but housing affordability is every bit the nightmare of Sydney and other costs of living reflect its isolation and lack of competition.

Henderson concedes the government has been tardy in its planning and land releases. But he knows, too, that to flood the market with cheaper housing - if that was achievable - would push down the value of existing homes. And that can mean political death.

Darwin has always been costly but development brings its own pressures, applying the dual speeds of disparate economic opportunity. "There's an old cliche that you can't stop progress," says Jack Ah Kit, 10 years a Labor MP and 20 years involved in Aboriginal politics. He's seen Darwin grow from 3500 in the 1950s of his childhood to 127,000.

"I love the new Darwin," he says. "You can pine for the sleepy town … but inevitably we had to grow. For the last 20 years, I've watched people come to the Territory to get an experience, and it grows on them, because they come back."

Chris Delaney shifted from Melbourne for two years to practise law and for his wife, Lynette, to teach. That was 22 years ago. A Vietnam veteran who serves in Norforce, a mostly Aboriginal reservist outfit, he argues appalling indigenous living conditions will remain while education in remote communities sticks with priorities not sensitive to cultural need. But his experience is positive. "My wife describes it as a Victorian country town with palm trees. It's got a vibrant social life, emphasising the outdoors, and it's a great place to raise kids,'' he says.

"A dining experience here used to be a lump of steak, but international cuisine influences are now everywhere." Darwin has 56 nationalities. It's where the first boat people arrived and where many asylum seekers are incarcerated, and it was the destination for many fleeing East Timorese.

Perhaps Barack Obama's visit to Darwin last November, when he saluted the arrival of the first of 2500 US marines, aroused a sense of Darwin's national significance.

Or perhaps it was the summit last month with the Indonesian President, Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, who joked Darwin was a fitting venue given that most Indonesians' impression of Australia was formed watching Crocodile Dundee.

But individual appearances don't make a city, any more than catastrophes can snuff it out. In 1942, at least 243 people were killed in Japanese air raids on Darwin and Tracy, 32 years later, blew down 70 per cent of Darwin's buildings and killed 71 people.

Change is not always for the best, but it brings promise and opportunity, and sometimes relief. "You don't suddenly reach a nirvana," says Clare Martin, now living a quieter life on the staff of Charles Darwin University. "It's a work in progress. People talk nostalgically of times without air conditioning and electric fans, or without traffic jams, but I doubt they'd go back to it."

This story Administrator ready to work first appeared on Nanjing Night Net.

By admin, ago

Sisters at close range

Director Lynn Shelton, left, on set with Emily Blunt. Mark Duplass, Blunt and Rosemarie DeWitt in a scene from the film.
Nanjing Night Net

FILMMAKER Lynn Shelton knows all about working on a small scale, but she is also very certain about the possibilities it offers. Your Sister's Sister is, she says cheerfully, the third film she has directed that is basically ''one location with three characters''. It's also a movie made in the way she loves to work: in close collaboration with her actors. They are intimately involved in the development of their characters, and that's why her three leads are credited as ''creative consultants''.

The film begins with a wonderful, disconcerting scene at a wake. It's where we meet Jack (Mark Duplass), whose brother has died and whose response to the expressions of mourning takes people by surprise. Also present is Iris (Emily Blunt), the former girlfriend of the deceased.

She sends the numbed Jack to her family cabin in the Pacific north-west, where he can have time to himself. She plans to drop in on him. Neither is aware that Iris's half-sister, Hannah (Rosemarie DeWitt), will also be there, wrestling with uncertainties of her own. From this emerges a tale of alliances, expectations and observations, with some thoroughly surprising twists, which are comic, melancholy, meandering, poignant and awkward, often all at once.

It was Duplass who came to Shelton with the germ of the story, although his idea involved a mother and daughter, rather than two sisters. He had starred in her previous film, the equally lo-fi and confined Humpday, about two straight male friends who decide to make a gay porn movie together.

Until the last minute, the sisters were to be played by Blunt and Rachel Weisz. Then scheduling conflicts arose and Weisz had to withdraw.

Shelton was thrown at first. Everything was locked in for the shoot, she says, and she didn't have any leeway. Replacing Weisz at short notice didn't seem possible ''because I had built this character with and for her''. But when she found DeWitt, the extensive preparation meant she could offer her something solid on which to build. In a short time, Shelton says, ''we had to figure out how to get her stamp on the character''.

DeWitt - who played Don Draper's artist girlfriend Midge in Mad Men and Toni Collette's sister in United States of Tara - underwent intense preparation. She was handed what Shelton calls ''a scriptment'' - halfway between a script and a treatment - and a ''backstory bible; the story of these three people's lives up to the moment of the film taking place''.

Shelton, like director, writer and actor Duplass, is associated with a low-budget filmmaking aesthetic known as ''mumblecore'', which includes a commitment to improvisation and a sense of heightened naturalism. She wants her films to convey the feeling that the characters exist before and after the events onscreen.

Duplass is an effortless, inventive improviser, Shelton says. And Blunt's breakthrough film, Pawel Pawlikowski's My Summer of Love (2004), about a relationship between two teenage girls from different backgrounds, was based on improvisation. ''It was a film she loved working on,'' Shelton says. ''She had great memories of it and she wanted to work that way again.''

Improvisation, for her, involves certainties and possibilities, and ''having a map of the emotional dynamics of a scene''. The actors understand what the scene needs to convey, but have the freedom to explore ways of reaching it, ''and I'm the one that gets to pick''.

To Shelton, asking actors to plunge into improvisation means she prefers they speak in their own voices as much as possible - that they don't assume an accent, at any rate. Weisz and Blunt are English, but DeWitt is a New Yorker, and audiences might have been distracted by the fact that the sisters appear to come from different countries. However, Shelton says one of her earlier decisions turned out to be serendipitous. When she cast Weisz and Blunt, she decided that the characters were half-sisters. They are close, but there's a history of friction from childhood tensions about their parents' break-up. This point of difference, she says, became even clearer, without being unduly emphasised, when DeWitt came on-board.

Just before Your Sister's Sister, Shelton took a very different kind of creative assignment: she directed an episode of Mad Men, titled ''Hands and Knees''. It was a fairly momentous instalment that involved pregnancy, a panic attack and a visit to the Playboy Club. For Shelton, it was a wonderful experience that seemed utterly new, yet surprisingly familiar. ''I couldn't believe that I was working on my favourite TV show and I still pinch myself that I got the opportunity.

''It was my first time with a union crew, on a sound stage, in Los Angeles. So many new things, and yet I discovered that it was still exactly the same job.'' The scale was different: instead of a production designer, she had a team. ''We were making the same kinds of decisions about what was in the frame and how we covered the scene,'' she says. ''But in TV, as a director, you're trying to channel the creator's vision. I'm the captain of the ship, not the admiral of the fleet.''

She also directed an episode of the Zooey Deschanel sitcom New Girl and is set to do a couple more of them, as well as a new Fox show, Ben and Kate, from the producer of New Girl. She had wanted to do TV, she says, ''because I thought it would be a nice way to continue to make the kinds of movies that I really want to make''.

For now, she is in the editing suite working on a film called Touchy Feely, which she shot in April and May. It has a bigger cast; as well as working with DeWitt again, it also stars Ellen Page, Allison Janney, Josh Pais, Ron Livingston and Scoot McNairy. It's something different, she says: ''I was shooting on a tripod, ensemble cast and multiple storylines and it's really more of a drama. It has some laughs, but you wouldn't call it a comedy by any stretch of the imagination.''

Even then, she found herself ''fantasising about going back to the bare bones of three people and a room''.

■Your Sister's Sister opens September 6.

This story Administrator ready to work first appeared on Nanjing Night Net.

By admin, ago

In search of the real Thring

MANY have sought the ''real'' Frank Thring. The man in the devilish black outfits, the bling around the neck and the enormous sunglasses concealing the expression in his eyes - the legend goes that he was always putting on a show when in public; that the big, camp fellow with shuddering jowls and plummy diction was someone else when home alone, unguarded.
Nanjing Night Net

Thring died in 1994 and his father, Francis Thring, died in 1936 when the boy was only 10, yet the two had much in common, including the tendency to elaborately present themselves to the world.

It was, therefore, a great frustration to the man who wanted to write their life stories - Peter Fitzpatrick, an honorary professor in performing arts at Monash University - that neither man left behind significant written records. To find them for his book The Two Frank Thrings, Fitzpatrick had to do seven years of research and interviews, and although much fascinating fruit was borne, many questions remain, mainly to do with the Thrings' ''true'' selves.

We might look at the photos of them for clues, insights. There is the younger Thring - better remembered than his father - in visual records that give the impression he was more successful, famous and talented than he was: on his float as a King of Moomba, in his satanic guise on talk shows and ads, or in many shots of him playing ''tyrants in togas'' for Hollywood blockbusters such as Ben-Hur, El Cid and King of Kings (alongside Laurence Olivier, Kirk Douglas, Charlton Heston and Jeffrey Hunter), among others.

Then there are the photos of Thring snr, born in 1882: sideshow conjuror, impresario, speculator and legendary founder of Australia's first ''talkies'' studio, Eftee Films. He looks suave, confident and successful - just as the world believed him to be.

We can put pieces together with these pictures, yet forget biography is a tricky business, even when there are diaries and letters to inspect. Such records, Fitzpatrick says, are unreliable because the writers perform for an intended audience, biographer or historian. They overstate some things and understate others.

Fitzpatrick was struck that although Thring jnr had little to do with his father, they resembled each other physically to an astonishing degree, made their paths through life with similar strategies, and the boy was as ostentatious as his father was reserved.

''They both were clearly constructing the narratives of their own lives - Frank snr by being secretive and covering his dealings and constantly pretending to a respectability that he didn't really have, and his son by performing this extraordinary, flamboyant self all over the place,'' Fitzpatrick says.

''That kept people at bay from asking anything that was personally intrusive or revealing.'' As one journalist wrote on interviewing Thring jnr in the months before the performer's death, there was only a glimpse of ''the warm Frank Thring that people who know him talk about''. Otherwise, his persona was a deliciously waspish and entertaining artifice.

For Fitzpatrick, it was important in his 564-page book not to oversimplify the distinction between the performed self and the ''real'' self. As he writes in The Two Frank Thrings: ''The roles that we play are rarely so neatly separable from the selves that we are, and those selves are ambiguous and shifting, too; 'inner selves' can be as hard for us to know or acknowledge as they are for others to read in us, even if we can be certain they are there.''

To try to understand the Thrings, Fitzpatrick's book melds established facts about these two men's lives with small, fictional interludes that separate each chapter. These imaginings try to take us inside what Fitzpatrick suggests is the interface between their public and private selves.

As he says, along with careful historical research and interviews (with people such as Thring jnr's former wife, Joan), the fiction is based on ''informed supposition''.

''That's about as close as anyone's going to get.'' How, though, does one actually sum up another person's life?

''How would you identify the key points - what are the significant things of a life?'' he asks. ''Is the thing that makes a person a suitable biographical subject - which is usually some kind of distinction - is that where the weight falls, or does it fall on the hypothetical psychological forces that prepared them for that sort of choice and the ways in which they lived it?''

In The Two Frank Thrings, psychological forces are possibly the main character, if somewhat shadowy and submerged. Take, for example, the year-long marriage in 1955 of Thring jnr to Joan Cunliffe. It was the elephant in the room that Thring was homosexual - everyone knew - and there are many stories about the wedding and what did and didn't happen on the wedding night.

Fitzpatrick writes: ''Rumours about the circumstances of the Thring marriage were there from the beginning, multiplied hugely when it ended, and have kept growing ever since. Anyone who tries to disentangle fact and fiction, even at a distance of half a century, risks hurting some feelings or spoiling some good stories or both.''

Cunliffe (still going by the name Joan Thring) told Fitzpatrick that she and Thring truly loved each other; that he wanted to be married and have children. Frank's deep distress at the failed, childless marriage, Fitzpatrick says, ''passed into folklore as a comic turn'', the actor's ''self-directed humour'' part of a pre-emptive strike strategy.

As he says, the sorrows of life perhaps form us more decisively than the happiness, true of father and son. ''Any biography is likely in some way to have a revelation of regrets, unfulfilled ambition, unrequited love - but what makes biography interesting is often the resources people have drawn on to deal with that fact of their lives.''

Fitzpatrick brings such characteristics into detailed relief. For Thring snr, there must have been much internal wrangling about his personal life - a wife from whom he was estranged, the daughter he scarcely knew whose guardian he became, the overbearing second wife and the interesting son.

For Thring jnr, there was the inability to form an intimate relationship with someone appropriate. Elaborate flirtations with young proteges were, for him, largely about sentimentalising the beauty of youth, Fitzpatrick says.

''You could read it as someone whose own maturity had been arrested in some way, so he could never form a fully equal relationship with a person of his own generation. He had these very mentoring, paternalistic kinds of affairs which enabled him to behave a bit like his father in terms of being free with his money. He would lavish it on whoever the young man was he was taking out for a cherry brandy.''

Sadly, Fitzpatrick says Thring jnr ended his days with multiple illnesses, chronic insomnia and alcoholism, and dealing with his depression by being savage towards others. ''He was, fundamentally, a pretty lonely man.''

■The Two Frank Thrings, Monash University Publishing, $49.95. 

This story Administrator ready to work first appeared on Nanjing Night Net.

By admin, ago

Edwardian premise endures

Upmarket Brighton builder Nick McKimm is probably best known for his sleek, contemporary designs, but his portfolio does include period-styled projects, too.
Nanjing Night Net

So when it came to his family home, he saw the chance to combine old and new, deciding to transform a two-storey Edwardian-Federation period house in Brighton, which he bought from friends in 2007. The house, just 200 metres from the beach, had already undergone one makeover in the 1990s.

While Mr McKimm ended up building his family of five a house five minutes down the road in Yuille Street (where he has built seven houses), he saw the Park Street project through, completing the job in mid-2008.

Mr McKimm has largely retained the shape of the period facade, rendering the brickwork with a grey finish, replacing the terracotta roof tiles with a more sophisticated black and, most noticeably, replacing a left-side front sitting room with a three-car garage. He also added a balcony to the protruding upper storey, remodelled the supporting columns enclosing the porch and landscaped the front garden.

While significant sections of the original footprint have been retained, the inside has been gutted. To the right of a wide entrance sits a formal living room (originally the formal dining room), which leads to an L-shaped open-plan family, dining and kitchen area. Carpet has been used to separate subtly the formal and casual living rooms from the distinctive parquetry floor in the hallway and dining-kitchen area.

The warm tones of the timber floor help retain a period sensibility in a modern environment. The part-stone, part-timber island bench in the kitchen captures the same feeling.

Encased in full-height glass doors, the whole back area overlooks a north-facing deck with built-in barbecue and stone-clad outdoor fireplace, with a lawn on the east side of the garden. On the west side, a pool abuts a squat cabana with entertainment station, bar and bathroom, as well as bluestone decking and day beds.

From the back, the house roughly mirrors the front with a pair of traditional pitched roofs and timber-strip balconies. This mix of old and new almost gives the house a European alpine chalet look.

The first floor has been rebuilt rather than just renovated, as Mr McKimm planned, because the underlying structure was in poor condition.The back half has been raised and extended - replacing the original dormer - so the pitched upper level now covers the ground floor, creating a much larger footprint upstairs.

''I didn't go the flat roof or use Alucobond out the back, as so often happens,'' Mr McKimm says. ''Rather, I replicated the [existing] roof line, so it felt more traditional.''

A funnel-shaped skylight provides a modern touch above the American oak staircase. To the left at the top of the stairs, there is a cinema-rumpus room at the end of the corridor, and an extra storage area and balcony have been added. Two large bedrooms, either side of the landing, are much as they were, but now each has a walk-in wardrobe and en suite.

The corridor to the right leads past a third bedroom, with balcony and shared en suite, to the main bedroom. While not the largest main bedroom you've seen, it does have a huge dressing room, en suite and north-facing balcony. These areas are all part of the addition upstairs.

More than just a bigger footprint, the cathedral or vaulted ceilings upstairs - where the ceilings follow the rake of the roof line - make each of the rooms feel spacious and airy.

''It does sort of reinforce that feeling of living in a European-styled villa,'' Mr McKimm says.

This story Administrator ready to work first appeared on Nanjing Night Net.

By admin, ago

Seasonal delights

Tamie Fraser in her garden flanked by two 'Tamie' camellias.OPEN Gardens Australia is the second-largest scheme of its kind after Britain's National Garden Scheme, which also opens gardens to the public.
Nanjing Night Net

Like the NGS, which this year celebrates its 85th anniversary, its Australian contemporary is in celebratory mood, having reached a 25-year milestone.

The 2012-13 season of the Victorian division of Open Gardens Australia will be launched on Tuesday by the scheme's president, Tamie Fraser, at Rippon Lea Estate. The first garden to open tomorrow week will be Dame Elisabeth Murdoch's Cruden Farm, with its magnificent fields of daffodils.

Fraser, who has opened her Merricks garden a number of times and will open it for the last time in February, says owners who share their gardens with the public are very generous.

''It's such a privilege for people to go into someone else's private space and see what they have,'' she says. ''You do bare your soul when you open your garden to the public but you do get tremendous knowledge from people coming in to see your garden.''

The Frasers' hillside garden affords stunning views from the house and includes a section devoted to native trees, rose beds, hedges and perennials, including Malcolm Fraser's pride and joy, the camellia walk, which has been floriferous this year.

Other special events include the opening on September 16 of seven cottages at Bickleigh Vale Village in Mooroolbark, which were created by Edna Walling.

The annual plant fair will be held in March at Sir Roderick Carnegie's Woodend property Flint Hill, which features a large woodland garden with specimen trees underplanted with rhododendrons and azaleas, formal lawns and shrubberies.

Fraser says the plant fair is a popular event on the Open Gardens calendar, attracting 10,000 visitors when it was held at Thurulgoona, her property in Merricks.

In a first for the scheme, two twilight openings will be held on Australia Day: Bagnols, a French-inspired garden designed by Paul Bangay at Shoreham; and Rick Eckersley's Musk Cottage at Flinders, which will include musicians, wine and food.

Usually, the season ends on the Mother's Day weekend but this time it will continue through winter and include Gunyah, a large vegetable garden in Pascoe Vale, and Attila Kapitany's stunning display of architectural agaves, aloes and yuccas.

There will also be an Australian plants workshop and a ''conversation'' on Gardens and Gardening Today: Sustainability, Direction, Design, which will feature eight experts, including Carolyn Blackman, Phillip Johnson, Michael McCoy and Sharon Harris.

A tour of nine significant gardens in the Western District will be hosted by the organisation's chief executive, Richard Barley, and there is an opportunity to learn about palms from Jo Wilkins, a self-confessed ''palm-aholic''.

Open Gardens Australia grew from Victoria's open-garden scheme, established in 1987, to a national scheme in 2000. It was renamed last year to better reflect its role for the public.

Garden owners charge nominal fees to visit their gardens (the standard fee is $6), with 35 per cent returned to them or to a charity of their choice and 65 per cent to Open Gardens Australia, which receives no government money.

Each season, surplus funds are distributed to community garden projects under its Community Garden Grants Awards scheme. The recipients in the 2011-12 season were Buda house and garden at Castlemaine, to help with its garden restoration, and renewal works at the late Margot Knox's mosaic garden in Hawthorn.

■The new guide lists 500 gardens across the country and is available for $19 from opengarden南京夜网.au.


Going green

Greenlink indigenous plant nursery is holding its open day today from 9am-noon. 41 Wimmera Street, Box Hill North.

Karma camellias

Camellias Victoria is holding a display of camellias, including plant sales, today (1-5pm) and tomorrow (10am-4.30pm). Mount Waverley Community Centre, 47 Miller Crescent. $5. Also this weekend at the centre is the Waverley Garden Club's 50th anniversary of its floral art group.

Yellow hosts

The 56th annual Leongatha Daffodil and Floral Show runs from Thursday to Saturday at Leongatha Memorial Hall, McCartin Street, with flowers, plants and refreshments. $5. Phone 5668 6334.

Orchid spectacular

Thousands of orchids will be on display from Friday to Sunday at Springers Leisure Centre, 400 Cheltenham Road, Keysborough. 9am-5pm (Sunday until 4pm). Adults $6, concession $4. Phone 9786 1938.

Sexy spiders

On Tuesday, the Friends of Burnley Gardens will present a talk by Professor Mark Elgar about the sex lives of spiders and other interesting arachnid facts. Members $3, non-members $10. Quad 6, Burnley Gardens, 500 Yarra Boulevard, Richmond. 7pm for 7.30pm. Bookings essential, phone 9035 6861.


Japanese floral art (ikebana) will be exhibited from Wednesday to Saturday (10am-5pm) at Kazari Collector, 450 Malvern Road, Prahran.

Events to [email protected]南京夜网 two weeks in advance.

This story Administrator ready to work first appeared on Nanjing Night Net.

By admin, ago

Patients left in limbo as Alzheimer’s trial awaits ethical approval

IAN and Pat Cleaver ''made a mutual contract nearly 60 years ago, and that's not meaning a legal contract'', Mr Cleaver said. ''It's a contract between ourselves to look after one another.''
Nanjing Night Net

Mrs Cleaver's Alzheimer's disease makes her dependent on her 85-year-old husband, who still manages the couple's sheep and wheat property near Nyngan. Sometimes she joins him on the truck. Other times she spends a day at an aged care facility.

''Pat's not at an unworkable stage but I guess the progression of it means she will be,'' said Mr Cleaver, who hopes some of his wife's failing abilities will return if she can join a Queensland clinical trial of a radical new therapy.

But despite accepting more than $100,000 in donations from families of dementia patients, and signing up hundreds of potential participants such as 81-year-old Mrs Cleaver, Griffith University does not have the necessary research ethics approval to go ahead with the study, which will be limited to only 12 patients.

The proposal, to test a controversial drug injection technique that some relatives say produces stunning recovery, was condemned this week as cruel and unethical for raising unrealistic hopes and linking fund-raising to the possibility of participation.

A professor of medical education at the University of Sydney, Merrilyn Walton, said Griffith was ''overstating the results in a positive frame … to generate money from a particularly vulnerable group who are very interested in research, very invested in a cure.''

A professor of ageing and mental health at the University of NSW's dementia collaborative research centre, Henry Brodaty, said the study, which will not compare the drug to a placebo, would ''achieve very little. It's not going to give any definitive answers.''

Professor Brodaty said the treatment - which involves injecting the powerful immune system drug etanercept between the bones of the neck, then tilting the patient to trap it in brain fluid - was being promoted without sufficient scientific backing.

''I hope it works but until we've got more evidence … it worries me,'' he said. ''People get so excited and pin so much hope on this … I think it's cruel.''

The director of the Griffith institute of health and medical research, Lyn Griffiths, acknowledged the trial's future was uncertain. Three doctors would travel to California next week to receive training from the private clinic that pioneered the injections.

''We don't know whether they will complete the training or whether [the university's human research ethics committee] will be happy with it,'' she said.

The university would also need to find a hospital prepared to perform the procedure.

Professor Griffiths said the university had raised more than the $100,000 required for training, administration and drug supplies, and would not accept further money. After the Herald submitted questions, the university removed the donations button from the trial website.

Professor Griffiths defended the promotion of the trial. ''There's a real need for treatments,'' she said. ''I don't think there was any sense people were hoodwinked.''

Mr Cleaver is frustrated by the delay. ''They said quite emphatically they were ready to start,'' he said. ''We have this drug available and it doesn't seem logical not to use it.''

This story Administrator ready to work first appeared on Nanjing Night Net.

By admin, ago

Shelf space is fully booked

Anyone toying with the idea of writing a cookbook should visit my desk. That's not an open invitation but it could be a sobering experience.
Nanjing Night Net

The books desk - for want of a better description - groans beneath about 10 piles of 10 books apiece. All are relatively recent releases and the Christmas titles have not yet begun.

What shouts ''buy me'' above all others? A celebrity - preferably television - is the sure and fast way. As for the rest, it is endlessly fascinating to see how trends emerge.

Pretty is very 2012. After years of blinding white on white, book covers have images of lace, doilies and ornate spoons.

As for the recipes, why choose a snappy name when you can list almost every element? Hence Alice Hart has ''stuffed firepit venison with roast pear, port sauce and perfect mash''. If 1.3 kilograms of potatoes did anything less than caress my arteries with utter deliciousness when accompanied by 350 millilitres of single cream and up to 240 grams of butter, I'd be asking Macquarie to redefine ''perfect'' in the dictionary.

Pendolino restaurant's owner and chef, Nino Zoccali, has recipe names that read like an ingredients list. Take Pugliese tagliatelle with fresh and dried fava beans, salted dried ricotta, parsley, mint and basil. He writes: ''For those who have never heard of this dish …'' It's unusual, but barely a secret with that as a title.

Italian is also big in 2012, with Zoccali's offering joined by Giovanni Pilu's book on Sardinian food and Amanda Tabberer's travels down the Amalfi Coast.

Johnnie Mountain cooks with a passion for pork in Pig, which promises to demystify the meat. I'm not sure I'll take up his invitation with such dishes as toad in the hole with onion gravy. It looks very, um, English boarding school.

Prince Charles's stepson, Tom Parker Bowles, also offers toad in the hole, saying it was one school meal ''I actually found edible'', but spares us a picture. He gets the prize for the recipe with the weirdest name: ''A simple dish for bachelors and widowers to impress their guests''. The meal's main ingredient, chicken, is the same as his mum's classic recipe, although the future king's Camilla chops off ''that dangly bit'' above the cavity and puts it on top of the roast chicken. What dangly bit, I'm left wondering.

Parker Bowles confides his wife threatens to shove the recipe ''where the sun doesn't beam'' if she hears about it one more time. A choice little vignette on royal life.

Meanwhile, Bill Granger publishes Easy - or maybe that's a tautology. Can his recipes get any easier?

This story Administrator ready to work first appeared on Nanjing Night Net.

By admin, ago

Schools jittery as Gillard delays education reforms

THE federal government has delayed its long-awaited response to the first major review of school funding in 40 years amid anger over lack of consultation and concerns some private schools would be worse off.
Nanjing Night Net

The Prime Minister, Julia Gillard, was expected to announce the reforms early next week. However, a spokeswoman for School Education Minister Peter Garrett said it would now be ''in the next few weeks''.

The delay comes as the Victorian government, the Catholic Education Office and the Independent Schools Council of Australia warned some schools would lose out if the Gonski reforms were adopted.

This has been denied repeatedly by Mr Garrett, who insists no school will lose a single dollar.

Victorian Education Minister Martin Dixon said the delay suggested ''some of the real concerns raised by stakeholders are starting to bite''.

''It just shows you that they have gone into this whole process unprepared and with unreal expectations,'' Mr Dixon said. ''We run the second-largest [education] system in the country and they have not spoken to us in a realistic way. It has been an absolute travesty of the Federation.''

The Gonski review recommended the federal and state governments boost spending on education by $5 billion a year, based on 2009 figures, with the lion's share to go to public schools. The model aims to address disadvantage by allocating a standard amount for every student, with loadings for students with a disability and those from low-income, indigenous and non-English-speaking backgrounds.

The federal government is likely to contribute about $3 billion from 2014, with the states also required to chip in. Commonwealth funding will be conditional on the states agreeing to reforms to improve teacher quality, such as annual performance reviews.

The current funding model - which the Gonski report said was ''unnecessarily complex'' and lacked ''coherence and transparency'' - expires at the end of 2013.

Mr Dixon said this week it was ''just ludicrous'' for the federal government to suggest a new funding model would be in place for 2014. ''It just shows how out of touch it is and how it is just about getting over the hump of the next election.''

Federal opposition spokesman on education Christopher Pyne said the Coalition would support any legislation to extend the existing funding model for two years.

''We would be pleased if the government would take up our offer so schools can plan budgets. This current uncertainty is unacceptable and is creating real trouble in the non-government school sector amongst principals and governing councils who can't plan and parents who don't know what school fees are going to be.''

The Coalition has pledged to repeal any legislation to introduce the Gonski reforms if it is elected to government.

Modelling by the Victorian government showed more than 50 per cent of Catholic schools would lose funding, which the executive director of Melbourne's Catholic Education Office, Stephen Elder, said could result in fee increases of $800 to $6000.

The Independent Schools Council of Australia has also warned one in six private schools would be worse off and would have to raise fees.

But the federal government says the review panel modelling assumes government and Catholic education systems will redistribute funding to ensure no school is worse off.

Mr Elder told The Saturday Age last night the wait was making everyone nervous. ''We just want to know - the suspense is wearing everyone out unnecessarily.'' Independent Schools Victoria chief executive Michelle Green said: ''I think it's clear with something like this reaching agreement with the states and territories is not going to be easy.

[email protected]南京夜网.au

This story Administrator ready to work first appeared on Nanjing Night Net.

By admin, ago

Fear and loathing

Illustration: Simon LetchA series of graphic TV ads that are part of a new public health campaign show an off-putting substance as yellow and lumpy as boarding school custard roiling in a way that wouldn't be out of place in an Alien film. It is meant to be body fat, specifically ''toxic'' visceral fat that sits deep inside the body and smothers vital organs, such as the heart.
Nanjing Night Net

The Live Lighter campaign is a joint venture between the West Australian Heart Foundation and the Cancer Council, and its ads are based on the same behavioural principles as the highly successful National Tobacco Campaign, which has been confronting Australians with images of tarry lungs, gangrenous toes and oozing arteries since 1997.

Using anti-smoking-style tactics in a weight-management context is novel, but also controversial. Critics claim such campaigns compound the stigma surrounding obesity and that they have little effect. Some say scare tactics just make people shut down, a criticism that has also been aimed at road safety and skin cancer awareness campaigns.

However, Simon Chapman, the renowned tobacco control activist and professor of public health at the University of Sydney, says one of the most persistent myths surrounding public health is that ''scare tactics don't work''.

''Overwhelmingly, what you find from people who have made changes is that … it was fear about adverse consequences which motivated them,'' he says.

There have been attempts at positive health messages around tobacco control, he says, ''ads showing wholesome young people slotting basketballs through hoops … [but] they had zero cut-through; an absolute wallpaper effect.''

Research has shown that humour, too, is an ineffective motivator, says David Hill, a behavioural researcher and former chairman of the National Expert Advisory Committee on Tobacco, who has been instrumental in both the National Tobacco and Live Lighter campaigns. ''Non-smokers love humorous anti-smoking ads,'' he says.

When people criticise scare tactics, Chapman says, ''they are often getting confused with whether an ad is likeable rather than whether it is effective.''

Hill refers to the strategy used in the Live Lighter and National Tobacco Campaign ads as a ''doctor's-eye view'' rather than a scare tactic. ''[The NTC] was called a shock and a scare campaign, but it's the truth. It's actually showing what's going on in there. I think we face a similar situation with overweight/ obesity. The trends are awful and, at the very least … we owe it to the public to show what's really happening inside their bodies.''

Both Chapman and Hill do acknowledge, however, that obesity brings a special set of challenges.

There are people, Chapman says, ''who do have physiology that makes it very difficult for them to lose weight … and there is a serious discussion to be held about the consequences for those people who feel they are being stigmatised and left behind.''

''Losing weight is tougher, I accept that,'' Hill says. ''But these are desperate times so we have to try.'' A comprehensive series of evaluations is in place to track the effectiveness of the campaign over time, he says.

The author of Fat Chance: My Big Fat Gastric Band Adventure, Melanie Tait, 32, was put on the first of many diets at age seven. The result? By 2009, when she underwent weight-loss surgery, she had about 50 kilograms to lose. Tait has now lost a lot of that weight but says she still battles daily with appetite and a body that's reluctant to shrink.

Asked to look at the Live Lighter ads, she admires the production values and agrees the graphic images ''certainly stick in there … but at the same time I don't think fat people need to be associated with being toxic any further than they already are.

''I think it would give pause to anyone who does have a weight issue but, that said, I don't think there are many people who are overweight or obese who aren't already well aware of what it's doing to their body. They already know it's a problem and they wish they could fix it.''

This story Administrator ready to work first appeared on Nanjing Night Net.

By admin, ago